Actually,
You Can’t Make the Earth Heavier
Put up buildings, add more people: the Earth’s weight stays the same. In fact, the Earth gets a little lighter every year. Let’s put it on a scale and find out!
Let’s go1First, what are “materials”?
Buildings, trees, your own body. Everything on the Earth is made of materials that were already on the Earth.
Pick one and follow where its materials came from.
In Depth
This page describes atoms moving from one place to another, unchanged, as “materials changing places.” In a chemical reaction atoms are rearranged, but none are created or destroyed (conservation of mass). Most of a tree’s dry mass is carbohydrate made by photosynthesis from carbon dioxide in the air and water; minerals taken up from the soil are only a few percent. The atoms in a human body likewise come from food, water and the air we breathe, and most are replaced within a few years.
2Build all you like, same weight
We put the whole Earth on a scale. If we put up buildings and add more people, will the needle move?
Slide to the right and build more and more.
In Depth
The Earth’s mass is about 5.97×10²⁴ kg. Everything humans have made (buildings, roads, machines and so on) is estimated at about 1×10¹⁵ kg, but all of it was taken from the crust, the oceans and the atmosphere, so it does not change the mass of the Earth as a whole. Most objects launched into space remain in orbit around the Earth; the mass of probes that have left the Earth’s gravity is tiny. Strictly speaking, energy flowing in and out also changes mass (E=mc²). The heat the Earth is storing through global warming corresponds to roughly 160 tons a year, far smaller than the flows of matter in the next chapters.
3What falls in from space
Then what about things that come from outside the Earth? Rocks and dust fall in from space every day.
Tap the sky to drop a shooting star.
In Depth
Almost all of the extraterrestrial material that falls on the Earth is cosmic dust (micrometeorites) too small to see. An estimate based on about 20 years of collection at Dome C in Antarctica puts the amount reaching the surface at about 5,200 tons a year, and the total entering the atmosphere at about 15,000 tons a year (Rojas et al., 2021). An older, widely used estimate was about 40,000 tons a year. This page gives the range as “10,000 to 40,000 tons a year.” Meteorites large enough to pick up account for less than 10 tons a year. Tons here are metric tons.
4What escapes from the sky
The Earth holds on to its air with gravity. But very light bits fly around so fast that gravity can’t hold them all.
Pick a kind of bit and see which ones escape into space.
In Depth
This page pictures atmospheric escape as thermal (Jeans) escape: lighter particles move faster, and only the fastest get away. At the base of the exosphere (about 500 km up) the temperature is about 1,000 K and hydrogen atoms move at about 5 km/s on average. That is below the escape velocity of about 10.8 km/s, but speeds are spread over a distribution, so the fast tail escapes. In reality charge exchange and the polar wind, which flows out along magnetic field lines, also contribute a large share of hydrogen loss, and helium is lost mainly through such non-thermal processes. The loss rates are about 3 kg of hydrogen and about 50 g of helium per second (Catling & Zahnle, 2009). Nitrogen and oxygen are heavy and are hardly lost this way. Neither hydrogen nor helium returns once it has left. The difference is supply: seawater holds a vast amount of hydrogen, while helium is produced only very slowly by the radioactive (alpha) decay of uranium and thorium underground, and what we use is extracted from natural gas deposits where it has collected.
5Compare them: the Earth is getting lighter
The dust coming in from chapter 3, and the gas escaping from chapter 4. Put them side by side over the same time, and far more gas escapes. The Earth gets lighter by the difference.
Yellow bits are dust coming in. Blue bits are gas escaping. Move the slider to run time forward or backward, and compare.
In Depth
The net figure is the outflow (hydrogen and helium, about 97,000 tons a year) minus the inflow (cosmic dust, about 15,000 tons a year): about 80,000 tons a year, or about 2.6 kg per second. With the older inflow estimate (about 40,000 tons a year) the net is about 50,000 tons a year; either way the outflow is more than twice the inflow. In the picture, “dust coming in” uses the newer estimate (about 15,000 tons a year, about 0.5 kg per second) and “gas escaping” is about 3.1 kg per second. The numbers of bits (3 of dust, 19 of gas) follow that ratio. Eighty thousand tons a year is about 1.4×10⁻¹⁷ of the Earth’s mass. Even if today’s rate had lasted for the Earth’s whole age of 4.6 billion years, the loss would be about 3.8×10¹⁷ kg, about one 16-millionth of the Earth’s mass (about 5.97×10²⁴ kg). For a person weighing 30 kg that is about 2 mg, roughly a grain of sand (a rough guide, since past loss rates were not the same as today’s). A change in mass this small has no measurable effect on surface gravity or on the Earth’s orbit. The hydrogen in seawater amounts to about 1.5×10²⁰ kg, enough to last more than a trillion years at the present rate. The loss is held down because water vapor freezes out in the cold layer of the upper air (the tropopause), so hydrogen-bearing molecules rarely reach the upper atmosphere. In about a billion years, when the Sun is about 10% brighter, this trap is expected to fail and water loss to rise sharply. The comparison weights are rough guides (African elephant about 4.5 tons, blue whale about 110 tons, Eiffel Tower about 10,100 tons; metric tons).
6Summary and Quiz
Summary
- What people make is just the Earth’s materials moved to a new place. So the Earth doesn’t get heavier.
- Only what comes in from space and what goes out to space can change the Earth’s weight.
- More hydrogen and helium escape than dust falls in. The Earth gets lighter every year.